Debating Transcendence: Creatio Ex Nihilo and Sheng Sheng
Paperback
Series: Comparative Theology: Thinking Across Traditions, Book 12
ISBN13: 9781531512095
Publisher: Fordham University Press
Published: Nov 4 2025
Pages: 336
Weight: 1.01
Height: 0.76 Width: 6.00 Depth: 9.00
Language: English
A bold and rigorous reexamination of transcendence--uniting religion, theology, philosophy, and science--while bridging Confucian and Christian thought to explore the origins of the world and human destiny
Debating Transcendence is a groundbreaking contribution to the ongoing dialogue between Confu-cian and Christian thought by addressing the transcendence debate--a key controversy that has shaped centuries of cross-cultural intellectual exchange. Song examines whether the Confucian concept of Tian (Heaven) or Taiji (Ultimate Limit) possesses a transcendent dimension comparable to Christian understandings of the Creator God. This study revisits the historical and philosophi-cal roots of the debate, tracing its evolution from early interactions between Confucianism and Christianity during the sixteenth century to present-day discussions. At the heart of this book is Song's aim to construct a Confucian definition of theology and a Confucian approach to comparative theology. Grounded in a scientifically rigorous methodology that transcends the conceptual boundaries of philosophy, religion, and theology, this new approach balances rootedness and impartiality, minimizing biases and revealing shared ground. Covering essential thinkers from the West and the East--such as Plato, Augustine, Descartes, and Paul Tillich alongside Confucius, Laozi, Wang Bi, and Zhu Xi--Song explores the historical development of key concepts such as creatio ex nihilo (creation out of nothing) and sheng sheng (birth birth), challenging misconceptions and highlighting underexplored commonalities and differences. Drawing from his diverse scholarly background and extensive engagement with both traditions, Song distinguishes Confucian from Daoist metaphysics and demonstrates that Confucian metaphysics, centered around the concept of generatio ex nihilo, offers a compelling framework for understanding transcendence that not only resembles but, in certain aspects, surpasses major streams of its Christian counterpart. Readers seeking to understand the profound spiritual foundations underpinning interactions between China and the West will find Song's work essential. Combining rigor, scope, and depth, Debating Transcendence paves the way for refreshed interactions between Confucian and Christian thought, offering insights vital to contemporary scholarship and interreligious exchange.1 different editions
Also available
Also from
Song, Bin
Also in
Confucianism
Book of Songs (Shi-Jing): A New Translation of Selected Poems from the Ancient Chinese Anthology
Confucius
Hardcover
Los Cuatro Libros de Confucio, Confucio y Mencio, Coleccion La Critica Literaria Por El Celebre Critico Literario Juan Bautista Bergua, Ediciones Iber
Confucio y. Mencio, Y. Mencio
Confucio Y Mencio
Bergua, Juan Bautista
Paperback
Korean Neo-Confucian Masters Series Vol.4: Yulgok Yi I: The Practice of Reverent Sincerity
Bae, Byeongdae
Hardcover
Understanding the Analects of Confucius: A New Translation of Lunyu with Annotations
Ni, Peimin
Paperback
History of Chinese Philosophy, Volume 1: The Period of the Philosophers (from the Beginnings to Circa 100 B.C.)
Youlan, Feng
Paperback
Confucius Analects (論語): A New Translation with Annotations and Commentaries
Li, Raymond K.
Paperback
Korean Neo-Confucian Masters Series Vol.1: Hwadam Seo Gyeong-deok: The Philosophy of Qi and the Great Void
Bae, Byeongdae
Hardcover
Korean Neo-Confucian Masters Series Vol.3: Nammyong Jo Sik: The Philosophy of Moral Integrity and Self-Cultivation
Bae, Byeongdae
Hardcover
Despertar del Tercer Ojo: Como activar tu chakra del tercer ojo y glándula pineal: Third Eye Awakening: How To Activate Your Third Eye Chakra and Pine
Rowland, Barbara
Martin, Sarah
Paperback
Korean Neo-Confucian Masters Series Vol. 2: Toegye Yi Hwang: The Metaphysics of Moral Principle
Bae, Byeongdae
Hardcover
The Arcane Teachings of Confucius: 42 keys to understand the three Chinese wisdoms: Buddhism, Taoism and Confucianism
Ming, Xiao
Zen, Lotus
Paperback
El Libro Canonico de La Historia de Confucianismo. Confucio. Traducido, Prologado y Anotado Por Juan Bautista Bergua.
Confucius
Bergua, Juan Bautista
Paperback
How Confucius Changed My Mind: And What He Can Teach You about the Art of Being Human
Jones, Charles B.
Paperback
A Matter of Life and Death: Administration and Officials in the Qing Dynasty Board of Punishments (1644-1906)/人命关天:
郑小悠
Paperback
左派和右派的理性对话
若缺
Paperback
Xiaojing The Classic of Filial Piety: Chinese-English Edition (Large Print Edition)
Confucius
Hardcover
The Ethics of Confucius: The Sayings of the Master - Confucian Teachings of Chinese Wisdom, Philosophy and Morality
Dawson, Miles Menander
Paperback
Learning of the Way (Daoxue): Self-Cultivation Through Neo-Confucian Learning, Kungfu, and Martial Arts
Young, John E.
Paperback
Zhu XI's Reading of the Analects: Canon, Commentary, and the Classical Tradition
Gardner, Daniel
Paperback
Recovering Confucian Authority: The Field of Ritual Learning in Early Imperial China 9 to 316 CE
Chard, Robert L.
Hardcover
Third Eye: Third Eye, Mind Power, Intuition & Psychic Awareness: Spiritual Enlightenment
McKenna, Alex
Hardcover
Korean Neo-Confucian Masters Series Vol.7: Nosa Gi Jeong-jin: The Defense of Right Learning and the Absoluteness of Li
Bae, Byeongdae
Hardcover
Zhu XI's Reading of the Analects: Canon, Commentary, and the Classical Tradition
Gardner, Daniel
Hardcover
The World of Wu Zhao: Annotated Selections from Zhang Zhuo's Court and Country
Rothschild, N. Harry
Hardcover
Natural Philosophy of Chu Hsi (1130-1200): Memoirs, American Philosophical Society (Vol. 235)
Kim, Yung Sik
Hardcover
Confucianism and Modernisation: Industrialization and Democratization in East Asia
Zhang, W.
Hardcover
Transition to Neo-Confucianism: Shao Yung on Knowledge and Symbols of Reality
Birdwhistell, Anne D.
Hardcover
New Horizons in Eastern Humanism: Buddhism, Confucianism and the Quest for Global Peace
Ikeda, Daisaku
Weiming, Tu
Hardcover
A Spiritual Geography of Early Chinese Thought: Gods, Ancestors, and Afterlife
Clark, Kelly James
Winslett, Justin
Hardcover
Seeking the Spirit of the Book of Change: 8 Days to Mastering a Shamanic Yijing (I Ching) Prediction System
Wu, Zhongxian
Paperback
Material Objects in Confucian and Aristotelian Metaphysics: The Inevitability of Hylomorphism
Rooney, James Dominic
Hardcover
Confucianism and Sacred Space: The Confucius Temple from Imperial China to Today
Huang, Chin-Shing
Hardcover
Essentials of Neo-Confucianism: Eight Major Philosophers of the Song and Ming Periods
Huang, Siu-Chi
Hardcover
Manufacturing Confucianism: Chinese Traditions and Universal Civilization
Jensen, Lionel M.
Paperback
The World of Wu Zhao: Annotated Selections from Zhang Zhuo's Court and Country
Rothschild, N. Harry
Paperback
Self-Realization through Confucian Learning: A Contemporary Reconstruction of Xunzi's Ethics
Tang, Siufu
Paperback
Confucianism and Sacred Space: The Confucius Temple from Imperial China to Today
Huang, Chin-Shing
Paperback
The Confucian Revival in Taiwan: Xu Fuguan and His Theory of Chinese Aesthetics
Sernelj, Téa
Hardcover
An Academic History of China's Han Dynasty: Volume II Brilliant Academic Achievements
Xiong, Tieji
Hardcover
Confucian Philosophy of Zhongdaology: Its Historical Origin and Contemporary Relevance
Xu, Keqian
Hardcover
