Sign-In
Cart
The Theory of Our Maybe: A small-town second-chance romance
Paperback
Series: Modern Love Stories
Publisher: Independently Published
Published: Jan 9 2026
Pages: 522
Weight: 1.52
Height: 1.16 Width: 6.00 Depth: 9.00
Language: English
Sometimes the future you planned is the one you have to rewrite-together.
When Chicago sociologist Dr. Maya Anderson is called back to Northwood, Michigan, to care for her ailing mother and fix up the decaying family home, she expects a short visit and a swift escape. She doesn't expect Ben Carter-the boy who once carved her a wooden bird, the carpenter who can still read the grain of her heart. Ten years ago, Maya left without a goodbye. Ben stayed and built a life with his hands and stubborn hope.
What begins with a busted porch and a stubborn treehouse becomes a cautious truce...then a spark neither of them can ignore. But Northwood remembers everything: the town potluck, the old mixtape, the ghosts of promises carved into wood. As a career-defining fellowship beckons Maya back to Chicago and a long-guarded family secret comes to light, both must decide whether love is a detour-or the destination.
From moonlit porch swings to sawdust-scented workshops, The Theory of Our Maybe is a slow-burn, heart-deep second-chance contemporary romance about rebuilding-houses, trust, and the future you thought you'd lost.
Perfect for readers who love:
Small-town, second-chance romance with big feelings and grown-up choices
A stoic carpenter hero and a brilliant, bookish heroine
Home renovation vibes, found family, and porch-swing nights
Slow-burn tension, tender kisses, and closed-door intimacy with an HEA
Themes of forgiveness, family, and choosing joy over perfection
Fans of Emily Henry, Katherine Center, and Abby Jimenez
What you'll find inside
Dual perspectives filled with chemistry, banter, and aching honesty
A poignant family mystery that reframes the past and opens the future
Real-world logistics (caregiving, careers, distance) met with creativity and heart
A love story that treats ambition and belonging as partners-not rivals
Maya's research calls it predictive nostalgia-the ache for a future that never happened. Ben calls it home. Together, they'll test a new theory: that love isn't a fortress to hide in or a dream to chase alone-it's a blueprint you draft side by side, then build with both hands.
Standalone contemporary romance with a guaranteed happily-ever-after. Some mild language; closed-door spice. Set in a vivid Midwestern town you'll want to revisit, with characters you'll miss the moment you turn the last page.
If you believe the best stories are the ones we build together, one-click The Theory of Our Maybe and fall for Maya and Ben's unforgettable second chance.
Also from
Bento, Alisson
The Obsidian Crown and the Thorned Heart: An Enemies to Lovers Fantasy Romance
Bento, Alisson
Paperback
A Court of Salt and Serpent: An Enemies-to-Lovers Fantasy Romance of Undersea Kingdoms and Forbidden Love
Bento, Alisson
Paperback
The Cruel CEO's Contract: An Enemies-to-Lovers, Forced Proximity Billionaire Boss Romance
Bento, Alisson
Paperback
Heart of Winter, Heart of Flame: A High-Stakes Romantasy of Siege, Sorcery, and Slow-Burn Desire
Bento, Alisson
Paperback
A Trial of Ash and Light: They were sworn enemies. Now, they are each other′s only hope.
Bento, Alisson
Paperback
The Fine Print: Love wasn't in the contract, but it was hidden in the details.
Bento, Alisson
Paperback
The Contraband Physique: The Prison-Style Guide to Bodyweight Fitness Without a Gym
Bento, Alisson
Paperback